A Night of the Most Excellent Order
A review of “The Beatles – a Night that Changed America, a Grammy Salute”.
Popular music and I have not said a
kind word to each other in over twenty years. That is why, up until the
afternoon of February 9, 2014,
I had no plans to watch the CBS Special “The Beatles – a Night that Changed America, a Grammy Salute”. It was taped some weeks
ago, but it aired 50 years to the day – to the hour – that the Beatles appeared
on Ed Sullivan. It was the most-watched television program up to that time.
Reading through the list of scheduled performers –
the ones hyped, that is – was akin to reading “Entertainment Weekly”. Page
after page of people I don’t know starring in TV shows and movies I don’t care
to see. The only group I had heard of was the reunion of The Eurythmics. Oh
joy. A combo I didn’t like 30 years ago are reuniting so I can dislike them all
over again.
But it was necessary to get the
public to pry themselves away from reality shows to watch musicians play songs
from fifty years before.
It wasn’t until previews were
available on Youtube that I decided to watch it. Well, Tivo it. Stevie Wonder
performed. Okay, so it’s not just “American Idol” rejects wailing their way
through the Beatle catalog. There was some talent involved.
Fortunately, instead of a parade of
the latest talent-less celebrities known more for their tongue and twerks, we
saw some fine performances!
And it was a great show! The
performers – all of them – did an excellent job! The bits in between the songs
were of more interest to me, but I was not disappointed by the performances.
The ones I knew, the ones I only heard of and the ones I never heard of – all
did superbly. I have no desire to run out and get their latest albums, but …
I had to look up the spelling of
some of the performers on Google, I apologize if I didn’t get them right…
The show started with the original
intro tag. Coming up next on the “The Ed Sullivan Show” … a great way to start
it.
LL Cool J gave us an introduction to
the reason for the special and introduced a clip from the “The Ed Sullivan Show”
– the Beatles performing “All My Loving”. It segued into Maroon 5 finishing the
song and they then performed “Ticket to Ride”.
Throughout the show shots of
audience members peppered the performances. Mostly they concentrated on Paul
and Ringo and their wives in the front row; but occasionally we saw Yoko and
Sean and George’s widow Olivia as well as other stars. I only recognized a few
of them.
Next came Stevie Wonder with his hit
“We Can Work It Out”. Rumor is he did it twice because he did not like the
first take. “Fire me, sue me,” he told the audience. It’s Stevie Wonder. He
could have done a dozen more…
And now we get to see the house band
– Peter Frampton doing his usual excellent guitar work. He was an uncredited
guitarist on George Harrison’s “All Things Must Pass” album. Steve Lukather, a touring member of Ringo’s All Starr Band
also played guitar excellently. Had he played this well with Toto they might
not have sucked. Kenny Aaronson played thunderous drums. He played with
everyone - EVERYONE – in the 1980s and I know him from the woefully
underappreciated album “HSAS” with Sammy Hagar and Neil Schon. The director
apparently loved Kenny too – they cut to him playing every six seconds or so.
Johnny Depp introduced the song
“Something” performed by rock veterans Joe Walsh and Jeff Lynne. They were
joined by George’s son Dhani. It was the only stage appearance by a
Beatle-spawn. Sean Lennon was in the audience but did not perform. Why didn’t
he?
Eric Idle appeared next, reprising
his role as the narrator/TV journalist from his “Rutles” specials. They gave
his character a name – Nigel Spasm (although his name was never given in the
original Rutles programs). He mentioned the Rutles performing that night 50
years ago. He was hilarious.
He introduced (and narrated) short
biographies of the Beatles beginning with John Lennon. John’s was the most
effective. It ended with the death of his mother and the line “… the love of
music his mother shared … would … transport him our of Liverpool and across the universe.” Lovely.
Why did they decide to colorize part
of the black and white photos in these biographies? We the People do not need
big, bright and loud colors to keep our attention; we can handle black and
white photos, thank you. Treat us like adults and we will start acting like
adults. Deal?
Next began a series of excellent,
excellent, walk-throughs and interviews with Paul, Ringo and David Letterman.
They discussed the studio, the set list, their choice of name, etc. It was
usually done after the commercial break and was one of the highlights of the
show.
Some of my favorite bits throughout were
interviews from women (girls) who were in the audience 50 years before. This
was peppered with Ed Sullivan performances of “I Want to Hold Your Hand” and “I
Saw Her Standing There.”
Kate Beckinsale (someone who starred
in movies I’ve not seen) introduced Ed Sheeran (a singer I’ve never heard of)
doing “In My Life”. He did an excellent job! Wonderful guitar work – I’d like
to learn his version of this song (which was performed at my wedding).
More audience shots. Ah, I recognize
someone – Tom Hanks! Tom Hanks was in an audience that had camera shots and
this was the first time he managed to get his mug in front one? Wow.
They showed a clip from “Let It Be”.
They got the rights to show a clip from “Let It Be”. This is akin to showing
footage of Bigfoot. It was the rooftop concert version of “Don’t Bring Me
Down”.
In the middle of the song it segued
into two singers named John Mayer and Keith Urban singing the song (ala “All My
Loving” at the beginning of the show). They cut off a clip of “Let It Be”. THEY
CUT OFF A CLIP OF “LET IT BE”. To use the previous analogy – is would be the
same as showing ten seconds of authenticated proof of Bigfoot then airing a bit
from “Harry and the Hendersons”.
Katy Perry managed to cover her cleavage long enough to sing “Yesterday”. There was some controversy when she changed
the lyrics by switching gender (“I’m not half the girl I used to be”). Oh, get
over it. Happens all the time. That is no controversy; leave her alone.
Then came the Beatles’ Ed Sullivan
performance of “She Loves You”.
An aside: strange that the two songs
most associated with the Beatles – not the most popular but the most iconic –
“I Want to Hold Your Hand” and “She Loves You” are the two least-covered songs
in their repertoire. They did not cut away to anyone “taking over” “She Loves
You” from the Ed Sullivan clip – whereas they did twice earlier in the show.
At this point, and peppered
throughout the rest of the show, were my favorite bits. Interviews with the
crew of the “Ed Sullivan Show” on that day 50 years ago. Bill Bohnert, art
director/set designer, John Moffett, associate director, and Vince Calandra Sr,
production assistant and George’s stand-in during rehearsal were interviewed
about their work on the show that day and during rehearsals. Bill tells the
story that Paul said, “We’ve always wanted to do ‘The Ed Sullivan Show’.” Funny, not a half-hour ago Paul said they had
never heard of “The Ed Sullivan Show” until they were booked on it. No one else
seemed to care …
There was a moving story of John
Lennon’s awe at standing in the same spot as Buddy Holly when he did Sullivan a
few years before.
LL Cool J introduced the song
“Revolution” performed by Imagine Dragons. “What!?” says I. “The kid’s band? Disney’s version of the Wiggles?” No, that was Imagination Movers – this is
Imagine Dragon. They did a very good acoustic version of the song.
Dave Grohl was next. He was in the
Foo Fighters and Nirvana with Kurt “what a weird bong” Cobain. He gave a moving
tribute, saying his mother had always been a fan of the Beatles; saying his
daughter is a fan of the Beatles; and lying about HE always being a fan of the
Beatles. I recall 22 years ago he and his fellow grungy ilk saying they don’t
like music by dead people.
They stopped saying that when Cobain
showed us what his brains looked like.
I guess being invited to a Beatles
tribute helped his love of the group along a bit.
That being said, he and Jeff Lynne
did a superb version of one of the Beatles’ best and least-known songs. “Hey
Bulldog”.
Back to Kate Beckinsale introducing
The Eurythmics. There is no “The” in their official name. When they were
popular they insisted that DJs NOT call them The Eurythmics, just Eurythmics.
So THE Eurythmics played “Fool on
the Hill”. I said that correctly – they PLAYED “Fool on the Hill”. If you recall The
Eurythmics were a purely electronic band; all computerized. Yet, when they
performed they had drums, back-up singers and guitars. “If they were true to
their art,” I said on the radio back in 1985 or so, “they would set up a
computer on stage, put in a floppy disk, press play and tell the audience to
enjoy the show.”
Annie Lennox has a lovely voice and
is a powerful singer, but I’ve never liked it personally – oil to my water. Dave
Stewart was once in a band in the 1970s called Longdancer. It was an EXCELLENT
group. And some of his post-The Eurythmics bands harkens back to those rock ‘n roll days. So The Eurythmics reunite. From the hype you’d think this was the
highlight of the show. It wasn’t. It was GOOD, mind you, but not the highlight
of the show.
Alicia Keys andf John Legend gave
testimonials and then gave their rendition of “Let It Be”. I had heard of them both but never heard
their music. I only knew of John Legend when I would joke about (ironically)
him being in the Beatles with Paul McKenzie.
John Legend has an excellent voice!
Alicia Keys … well, it’s like the issue I have with anyone – ANYONE – on
“American Idol”. I would have more respect for her talent if she could sustain
a solid note for more than two seconds. Was someone shaking her seat or does
she cover the entire musical scale with every note?
More bits with audience members and
crew members. Here they included reminiscings from Mitzie McCall and Charlie
Brill – a comedy duo who also performed on “The Ed Sullivan Show” that night! I
wanted more of this – I wanted to know who else was on the show as well as what
else was on that night? What did NBC and ABC air? This show’s main focus was on
the Beatles, true, but it was also focused on “The Ed Sullivan Show”, too. I
have the Beatles’ appearances on Sullivan on DVD, so I know who else was on
the show, but a few clips of the other performers wouldn’t have taken up much
time.
Actress Anna Kendrick, who starred
in movies and TV shows I’ve never seen, introduced the song “Here Comes the
Sun” and gave us a history of its writing. Would it have violated some law to
mention it was a hit for Richie Havens, who died last year? Pharrell Williams
and Brad Paisley, whom I have not heard of, performed the song with members of
Cirque du Freaks, er, Soleil pole dancing above them. Other members of
the circus troupe sat in front of them holding dolls. This circus troupe is popular
why?
Gary Clark Jr., Dave Grohl and Joe
Walsh did a rousing rendition of “While My Guitar Gently Weeps”. A fun moment
was the camera cutting away to Ringo who was miming Grohls’s drums. I love Joe
Walsh. He is an excellent guitar player and even shared some vocals here (not
his strongpoint one must admit). He, as well as the other two, was wonderful,
but … would it have been so hard to get Clapton? Really?
Jeff
Bridges gave a wonderful testimonial and introduced Ringo. Ringo then made us
forget the past hour and a half and stole the show. He perfomed “Matchbox”, “Boys”
and got the audience involved in “Yellow Submarine”. Musically, it was the
highlight of the show. And kudos to Ringo for introducing at least one member
of the house band – sometimes All-Starr Peter Frampton. Ringo gave a shout-out to Grohl and his daughter. You could tell Ringo was impressed with his drumming.
Sean Penn, who is looking more and
more like DeNiro, introduced Paul McCartney. After Ringo’s funfest this seemed
almost anti-climactic. Paul went through rote versions of “Birthday”, “Get Back”
and “I Saw Her Standing There”. The house band left and Paul performed with his
group. By now Paul could do these songs in his sleep. He nearly did. Too bad.
He had nothing to prove, true, but it was almost as if we were supposed to
enjoy McCartney being McCartney and not enjoying his performance.
Case in point: Paul did “Sgt. Pepper”.
He would have been forgiven if he changed the lyrics to “50 years ago today…”
The press would get on Kate Perry but not HIM. Just before Ringo joined him
onstage, Paul sang “Billy Shears”. He could have said “Ringo Starr”. The
audience would have loved it. I would have loved it! To me this shows how Paul
was going through the motions rather than relishing the moment.
Paul and Ringo have only performed
together (post-Beatles) once in 2010. So their “With a Little Help From My
Friends” was momentous and fun. Ringo brought back the enthusiasm he apparently
took with him from his previous set.
For the finale, “Hey Jude” they were
joined by the house band and the other performers and producers.
Yoko, Sean and Olivia never took the
stage. I think that was a wise move. They would have been given a standing
ovation, to be sure. But they were there to honor their husbands and father.
It was a wonderful program and I
enjoyed it very much. Probably not enough to rush out to get the DVD, but I
liked it and was glad I saw it.
I did have some problems with it: as
I said earlier, this was about the Beatles, but there was enough about “The Ed
Sullivan Show” to wonder why they didn’t talk about who else was on that “America-changing”
day” Why not show a clip of Frank Gorshin’s hilarious stand-up from that night?
Or a bit from Sophie Tucker?
Would it have hurt to have Mickey
Dolenz give a two-minute tribute to fellow-Monkee Davy Jones? He was on the
show too that night, doing a song from “Oliver” as the Artful Dodger.
Also, perhaps after two-and-a-half
hours the powers-that-be were afraid We the People would not have the
attention-span for another 50 minutes; but why not SHOW the entire Ed Sullivan program from
February 9, 1964. It couldn’t have been a question of acquiring the rights –
they showed a clip from “Let It Be” for god’s sake!
And where the hell was George
Martin?
Copyright 2014 Michael G Curry
Between
acts I peel off the white beard and mustache, the string tie and the white suit
and pants. A fellow actor touches up the black mustache and goatee, another
helps with the spats. I switch glasses, fluff up my ascot, put on my Panama hat
and I have been on time every since. 
